Calling 90% of your vote bank as "cattle-class" and "holy cows" on a public domain might not be the political acumen that people like Mr. Amar Singh of the Samajwadi Party are known for. Therein lies the difference between 'them' and Mr. Shashi Tharoor - a difference now tom-tommed by Mr. Tharoor's defenders. Also, compare the "holy cows" post to one of the "bloody natives" phrase used by caricatures of loyal 'sahib' stereotypes during the Raj (white or brown) and the "If they don't have bread give them cakes" phrase attributed to Marie Antoinette. These are used to portray the chasm of condition and mindset between the plebeians and the patricians - generally at the expense of the latter.
Bad idea coming into politics, Mr. Tharoor. A fantastic education, a career diplomat, successful author of a bestseller (wherein he compared the Congress Party to the Kaurava Army from the Mahabharat and Mrs. Indira Gandhi to Duryodhana - but that was a long time ago!) and a person who nearly became Secy. Gen of the UN - this was the last place he should have gone to. A person who comes under the sub-head of what I believe the Bengalis call the Bhadralok (I didn't know the Kerala equivalent) is simply not ready for the House of the People. Why? Because you have to deal with the People. And the result? Kiss goodbye to all those happy hours of laughing and joking about the Great Indian Populace. Their idiosyncrasies. Those soppy soaps on TV, the chalta hai attitude, all that hypocrisy in the name of religion, caste etc. And the Sarkar - boy, it's a gold mine for clever observations. All those over-earnest Babus and ministry zombies, the convoluted procedures of the sarkar, the chest-thumping patriotism and party-politics, the extended tea breaks - really gave a lot of material for another book. And what did we leave behind? Beautiful company, where they sip Whisky and Soda, call each other "Old Boy" or "Old Man" and say things like "Good show, Tharoor, that's telling the buggers", shake their heads at how incredibly foolish the bureaucracy actually is and how these buffoons run the show at the Parliament, reminisce about the time good old Johnny hit a 124 n.o. and the Stephanians lifted the Cup.
We all have prejudices. Writers in India depend upon their countrymen's caricatures to fuel some really snappy writing based on biting satire and dry scorn. Brilliant intellectuals, who were heads of the Drama Club at Stephens and took a Blue at Oxford, heap derision on our "provincial" mentality and our 'Hindu Rate of Growth' (Hindoo?). People like Morarji Desai, Lalu Yadav etc were prime targets. But you do these things within the safe confines of the Gymkhana Club or the IIC, not in Paharganj or Faridabad. There, you meet the subject-matter of your prejudices. Maybe we as people just don't "get it." Maybe we don't have a sense of humor. Maybe our education is based more on utility than on the Classics. Or maybe we draw a line at being called cattle. The possibilities are many. The bottom-line is that as a Minister, you can't let your true feelings show. Not on Twitter. That's being a little too spontaneous. Gets you compared to Bertie Wooster. "Calling a spade a spade" his defenders argue - not a defense Mr. Tharoor would be comfortable with, which helps my view that politics - anywhere in the world - is about the politically-correct.
It may be argued that Mr. Tharoor has done more in his lifetime than any of our glorious MP's combined. He is definitely one of the most intelligent. But sons-of-the-soil know more about the ordinary man than Mr. Tharoor. They may not fulfill the common man's wishes, they may ignore their cries and may usurp their money - but they won't call them (or worst, their party leaders) 'holy cows.' It is too sanctimonious and I feel that Mr. Tharoor, should he manage to put this past him, should be more careful in the near future. Or if he doesn't want to play the 'game' and display more integrity than the average Mantri, he will be welcomed back to the hallowed intellectual circles where we will once again be privileged to get his views on all things convoluted. A little prejudice may be a good thing after all!! Ivory Towers zindabad.